
Played by: Elizabeth Berrington
First Appearance: Touched
Lucy Best is one of the earliest and most formidable residents of St. Romaulda’s Orphanage, a Touched woman whose breaker touch allows her to shatter anything she touches with her bare hands. Her turn revealed itself in the most devastating way imaginable: when she lifted her six‑month‑old son from his bassinet, every bone in his body broke. The tragedy defined her life, leaving her grieving, furious, and determined never to let her power harm another innocent. Lucy’s mother had run with the Forty Elephants gang, and Lucy carries that legacy in the elephant‑head brooch Penance Adair crafted for her — a symbol of the life she lost and the strength she refuses to relinquish.
At the Orphanage, Lucy quickly became both protector and instructor. She taught the girls to defend themselves without relying on their turns, understanding better than anyone the danger of uncontrolled power. She confronted Inspector Frank Mundi during the police raid, attended Lavinia Bidlow’s charitable fete, and displayed her breaker touch for the guests by exploding china in her gloveless hand. Lucy’s loyalty to the Orphanage seemed absolute: she broke down the door of the false Orphanage address, stunned the jawless masked attacker with the electroshock umbrella, and helped Désirée Blodgett interrogate the woman responsible for murdering her own Touched daughter. Her rage at injustice was immediate and visceral, barely contained by the gloves she wore to protect others from her touch.
Lucy’s grief and anger made her susceptible to manipulation. After Mary Brighton’s death, she joined Amalia True and Bonfire Annie in planning retaliation against Lord Massen. But inside the warehouse, Amalia exposed the truth: the crates Lucy claimed held explosives were filled with rocks, and Lucy had known details about Massen’s office she should never have seen. Amalia confronted her, piecing together that Lucy had been working as a mole for Massen. Lucy insisted she never meant for Mary to die, claiming Massen had promised her a cure for her turn — a chance to stop being a danger to everyone she touched. The confrontation turned violent, with Lucy cracking the concrete beneath Amalia to escape, only to return for her elephant brooch and find herself staring down the barrel of Amalia’s gun.
Amalia spared her life, but Lucy’s betrayal fractured the Orphanage. She agreed to give Amalia everything she knew about Massen, beginning with the location of his true munitions storage. Lucy’s future remains uncertain — torn between guilt, desperation, and the faint hope that her turn might one day be cured. She is a reminder of how fear and grief can twist even the strongest into dangerous alliances, and how the Touched, for all their gifts, remain painfully human. In the history of the Orphanage, Lucy Best stands as both protector and betrayer, shaped by tragedy and driven by the impossible desire to be harmless again.
APPEARANCES
EPISODES












